Are you searching for comprehensive and affordable insurance coverage in New York State and the surrounding communities?

Since 2013, Maguire Insurance Agency has been dedicated to protecting what matters most to you. With over 30 years of collective insurance experience, our trained professionals offer personalized service and expertise to help individuals and businesses safeguard their assets,future, and peace of mind.

We’re Your Local, Full-Service Insurance Agency

Maguire Insurance Agency delivers a smarter, easier way to shop for insurance in New York State. With offices in Ithaca, Trumansburg, and Syracuse, our licensed agents offer the face-to-face guidance and community-focused service that online-only agencies simply can’t match. Whether you’re protecting your home, vehicle, business, or employees, we compare policies across 400+ insurance carriers to secure the best coverage and price for your unique needs.

As part of the Maguire Automotive Group, we offer a convenient one-stop solution for customers who want streamlined protection for their vehicles—but you don’t need to buy a car from Maguire to take advantage of our insurance services. Everyone is welcome.

Fast, Easy, Hassle-Free Insurance Quotes

Introducing Maguire Quick Quote – Getting insurance shouldn’t feel like a chore. With Maguire Quick Quote, you can simply, and securely, upload your current policy declarations to our portal. Our team will review your existing coverage, compares options across hundreds of carriers, and come prepared with personalized recommendations before you ever pick up the phone.

This means:

• No long phone calls
• No frustrating back-and-forth
• No starting from scratch
• Faster results with highly accurate comparisons

It’s insurance done on your schedule—and designed around your life.

Experience You Can Trust

With over 30 years of protecting individuals, families, and businesses, our agents bring deep expertise and real-world knowledge to every policy review. We take time to understand your goals, risks, and changing needs.

We offer complimentary annual coverage reviews to ensure you stay properly protected as your life evolves—new vehicles, new homes, new drivers, business growth, and more.

Personalized Service. Local Support. Real Peace of Mind.

We don’t just sell policies—we build relationships. Our agents work and live in the same New York communities you do. We’re here for walk-ins, scheduled appointments, or quick support when something happens. That local presence creates reliability and trust you can’t get from a national call center.

Our Insurance Solutions

Auto Insurance – Protect your vehicle with comprehensive options from 400+ carriers. Property Insurance – Homeowners, renters, and landlords trust our expert coverage. Personal Insurance – Life, umbrella, valuables, and more—customized to your needs. Business Insurance – Smart protection for small businesses and growing companies. Employee Benefits – Affordable, competitive benefit packages for your workforce.

Get Started Today

Whether you prefer a quick digital quote, a phone conversation, or a face-to-face meeting, Maguire Insurance Agency makes insurance simple, personal, and stress-free.